logo

English
                 

Vitamin D & Cancer Incidence in Older Women

JAMA; 2017 Mar 28; Lappe, Watson, et al

April 11, 2017

Supplementation with vitamin D3 and calcium compared with placebo did not result in a significantly lower risk of all-type cancer at 4 years among healthy postmenopausal older women, a recent study found. The randomized clinical trial included 2,303 women (mean age 65.2 years) with a mean baseline serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D level of 32.8 ng/mL. The treatment group (vitamin D3 + calcium group) received 2,000 IU/d of vitamin D3 and 1,500 mg/d of calcium; the placebo group received identical placebos. Researchers found:

  • At year 1, serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels were 43.9 ng/mL in the vitamin D3 + calcium group and 31.6 ng/mL in the placebo group.
  • A new diagnosis of cancer was confirmed in 109 participants, 45 (3.89%) in the vitamin D+ calcium group and 64 (5.58%) in the placebo group (difference, 1.69%; = .06).

Citation:

Lappe J, Watson P, Travers-Gustafson D, et al. Effect of vitamin D and calcium supplementation on cancer incidence in older women. A randomized clinical trial. JAMA.2017;317(12):1234-1243. doi:10.1001/jama.2017.2115.

Commentary:

The Vitamin D Hypothesis (vitamin D protects against cancer) was proposed in 1980 after the observation that colon cancer mortality rates in the US were highest in areas with the least sunlight. Subsequently, a number of studies have shown an inverse relationship between risk of cancer and serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D (25[OH]D) levels. Looking only at this study's findings might lead to the conclusion that the epidemiologic association of low vitamin D levels with cancer was supported when examined with the rigor of randomized trial research, and that supplementing with vitamin D does not decrease the incidence of cancer. We should be careful before making this conclusion, however. The rate of the development of cancer was almost 40% higher in the placebo group than in the vitamin D group, just missing statistical significance (p=0.06). It may well be that there is a substantial benefit of vitamin D supplementation, but the number of patients enrolled in this study was not sufficient to detect this benefit. In addition, since many cancers have a prolonged preclinical phase, 4 years may not have been long enough to detect a benefit to supplementation, even if one exists. Finally, the average vitamin D level of women in this study was normal, so a lack of benefit in this group does not exclude a benefit in the large number of individuals who have low vitamin D levels. In my opinion, this study suggests that there may be a relation between low vitamin D levels and the development of cancer, and that vitamin D supplementation may help, but additional longer and larger studies are needed before this hypothesis can either be supported or refuted. —Neil Skolnik, MD

No. Subject Date Author Last Update Views
Notice How to write your comments onto a webpage [2] 2016.07.06 운영자 2016.11.20 17771
Notice How to Upload Pictures in webpages 2016.07.06 운영자 2018.10.19 31857
Notice How to use Rich Text Editor [3] 2016.06.28 운영자 2018.10.19 5499
Notice How to Write a Webpage 2016.06.28 운영자 2020.12.23 43429
8832 돌아오는 기러기 [1] 2024.03.27 정관호*63 2024.03.28 17
8831 이강인-손흥민 ‘골 합작’ 한국, 태국 3-0 완승…월드컵 최종 예선 진출 성큼 [2] 2024.03.26 황규정*65 2024.03.27 11
8830 1945년 8월 15일 오후 강릉 홍제정 안마을에서 [2] 2024.03.19 정관호*63 2024.03.24 57
8829 이승만은 왜 김구를 제거 했을까? [1] 2024.03.17 온기철*71 2024.03.18 35
8828 My Grandson [1] 2024.03.15 노영일*68 2024.03.18 77
8827 蜀相(촉상): 촉한 승상 제갈량 [1] 2024.03.15 정관호*63 2024.03.15 34
8826 1945년 8월15일에는 서울에 아무일도 없었다. [1] 2024.03.13 온기철*71 2024.03.14 34
8825 왕소군 고향에서 [1] 2024.03.08 정관호*63 2024.03.20 37
8824 정약용; 늙어가면 친구가 점점 없어진다. [5] 2024.03.06 온기철*71 2024.03.08 65
8823 Trump is OK to be a candidate. 2024.03.04 온기철*71 2024.03.17 46
8822 AMAZING GRACE [1] 2024.03.01 정관호*63 2024.03.08 50
8821 한국에의 복수국적 - 이중국적이 더 불리한 경우를 알려 드립니다 [1] 2024.02.24 운영자 2024.02.24 67
8820 신진서, 농심배 16연승... 중국 기사 올킬로 한국 4연속 우승 [1] 2024.02.23 황규정*65 2024.02.23 39
8819 古朝鮮:고조선 [1] 2024.02.23 정관호*63 2024.02.26 41
8818 한국진공작전; Eagle Project and Napko Project [2] 2024.02.22 온기철*71 2024.02.28 87
8817 일제의 김구 암살 공작과 밀정 [2] 2024.02.19 온기철*71 2024.02.22 73
8816 장개석은 한국에 친중정부가 수립 되게 하려고 임정을 도왔다. [1] 2024.02.17 온기철*71 2024.02.24 80
8815 봄날의 원망 [1] 2024.02.16 정관호*63 2024.02.16 36
8814 내 마음은 가을 달 [1] 2024.02.08 정관호*63 2024.02.14 470
8813 1945년8월15일은 과연 해방이었을까? [2] 2024.02.06 온기철*71 2024.02.07 62