2015.11.02 11:27
2015.11.09 17:06
2015.11.09 17:30
The above contradictory comments comes from this (or similar) wrtings below.
After having read Edward Said's articles, I am sort of confused as well.
Since the publication of Edward Said's Orientalism in 1978, however, much academic discourse has used the term
"Orientalism" in reference to a patronizing Western attitude towards Middle Eastern, Asian and North African societies.
In Said's analysis, the West essentializes these societies as static and undeveloped—thereby fabricating a view of Oriental culture
that can be studied, depicted, and reproduced. Implicit in this fabrication, writes Said, is the idea
that Western society is developed, rational, flexible, and superior. (Quote from Wikipeda)
Two statement by Dr. On.
1. "1978년에 Edward Said라는 학자는 oriental(동양)을 static, undeveloped, inferior로 규정하는 데..."
No, Said didn't say that.
It was the western atttude, not Said's attitude. On this, I agree with Dr. JH Choh.
2. "싸이가 서양인들의 동양인을 얕 잡아 보는 풍조를 없에는 데 일조를 한 샘이지요...."
Yes, I agree. This is what "Psy of Korea" did, and also "Said of Palestine" did the same thing.
Here, I am going to add my own personal opinion (or interpretation) about these confusions.
I have read other articles about Edward Said to reach this conclusions.
1. "Edward Said" said that westerners tend to consider orientals as "static and undeveloped"
while they (the westerners, not Said) consider themselves as "developed, rational, flexible, and superior."
2. Remember that Said did not say such things, but it was the Europeans who said such things.
3. Initially, the "orientalism" referred to the mideast area, not the rest of Asia.
4. But, later, the concept was expanded to cover southern Asia, India, eastern Asia, and even northern Africa.
In the original definition of "orientals", it meant mideast Asia only, not the whole Asia.
I am not sure it ever covered "Far eastern Asia". I don't think it did.
5. "Edward Said", as a Palestinian, is the person who "criticized" European for being derogatory to the orientals.
6. "Said" hated the Arab rulers but never was derogatory to his people or his ancestral homeland.
(Just like we hate Korean politicians but never hate our homeland.)
I hope I got it understood correctly but I am not absolutely sure about it.
2015.11.12 14:39
No. | Subject | Date | Author | Last Update | Views |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Notice | How to write your comments onto a webpage [2] | 2016.07.06 | 운영자 | 2016.11.20 | 17768 |
Notice | How to Upload Pictures in webpages | 2016.07.06 | 운영자 | 2018.10.19 | 31852 |
Notice | How to use Rich Text Editor [3] | 2016.06.28 | 운영자 | 2018.10.19 | 5494 |
Notice | How to Write a Webpage | 2016.06.28 | 운영자 | 2020.12.23 | 43427 |
123 | Trader Joe’s 김밥 공장 [1] | 2023.09.03 | 온기철*71 | 2023.09.08 | 74 |
122 | 의대 불랙홀 [2] | 2023.05.27 | 온기철*71 | 2023.05.29 | 85 |
121 | 중국인과 한국인은 어떻게 다를 까? [1] | 2023.03.26 | 온기철*71 | 2023.03.29 | 150 |
120 | 한국 저출산의 원인과 해결 책은? [2] | 2023.03.14 | 온기철*71 | 2023.03.18 | 83 |
119 | Good Samaritan for Korean tourists in Buffalo during Xmas [1] | 2022.12.28 | 온기철*71 | 2022.12.28 | 66 |
118 | Basic human form is female. Maleness Is a kind of birth defect. | 2022.07.03 | 온기철*71 | 2022.07.03 | 142 |
117 | 어느 미용사의 꿈 | 2022.06.04 | 온기철*71 | 2022.06.04 | 63 |
116 | BTS meets Joe Biden at WH | 2022.06.01 | 온기철*71 | 2022.06.01 | 49 |
115 | 반지성주의 [1] | 2022.05.19 | 온기철*71 | 2022.05.19 | 65 |
114 | 한국인이 가장많이 사망하는 나이는? | 2022.05.10 | 온기철*71 | 2022.05.10 | 83 |
113 | 교수 자녀 의대 입학 [3] | 2022.04.18 | 온기철*71 | 2022.04.19 | 87 |
112 | Korean Vegan; Joanne Lee Molinaro | 2021.12.14 | 온기철*71 | 2021.12.14 | 97 |
111 | 미명문대 교수; 한류는 한국의 소프트 파우워 [4] | 2021.10.24 | 온기철*71 | 2021.10.28 | 73 |
110 | 일본 의리 한국 정 미국 계약 | 2021.10.23 | 온기철*71 | 2021.10.31 | 251 |
109 | 일본이 미국을 따를 수 없는 이유 [6] | 2021.10.15 | 온기철*71 | 2021.10.31 | 151 |
108 | 자유가 없으면 창작도 없다. [1] | 2021.10.04 | 온기철*71 | 2021.10.04 | 66 |
107 | 복날이면 보신탕인데요…. [3] | 2021.07.05 | 온기철*71 | 2021.07.08 | 61 |
106 | Amazing Dancers from SK in AGT | 2021.06.30 | 온기철*71 | 2021.07.01 | 53 |
105 | Wild Life in DMZ [5] | 2021.06.27 | 온기철*71 | 2021.06.28 | 69 |
104 | 태권도 in AGT Golden Buzzer [9] | 2021.06.19 | 온기철*71 | 2021.06.21 | 73 |
조중행*69 동문의 comment를 대신 아래에 올립니다.
(He was not successful in uploading a comment here.)
****************
우연히 들어왔다가 " Edward Said 의 orientalism 이 동양을 static, undeveloped, inferior라고 규정 헀다"는
comment 에 동의 할수 없다는 것이 전문가는 아니지만 저의 생각입니다.
이 Palestine 출신의 철학자 겸 ,영문학자는 대부분의 서양 media(많은 중동인은 Terrorist), 음악( for example...)
나비부인 , Miss Saigon).문학등..에서 동양, 중동 문화 가 inferior 한것으로 묘사된것에 반대라고 할까
서양 제국주의 식민주의에 근거한 서양사람들의 편견의 결과라고 생각한 사람으로 알고 있읍니다.
이러한 노력의 결과 친구 Jewish musician Daniel Barenboim 과 같이 Israrael 음악인들과 Palestine
또 다른 중동의 음악가들을 모아 West-Eastern Divan Orchestra를 창립, 활동하지 않았나 하는 것이 제 개인적 생각입니다.
저도 Said 의 글을 다시 자세히 읽어 보겠읍니다.
조중행