logo

English
                 
Could Detroit's tragedy have a silver lining?

July 22, 2013: 8:48 AM ET By Mohamed A. El-Erian



    "FORTUNE" -- The strong and impressive recovery of the U.S. auto
    industry has proven insufficient to prevent the proud "Motor City"
    having to declare bankruptcy.
    The next steps involve difficult and complex legal and financial issues,
    some of which conflict with traditional concepts of social justice.
    There are also questions as to whether this largest-ever city bankruptcy
    in American history will have negative impacts that extend beyond
    a community that has already suffered through too many tragedies.
     
    Detroit's bankruptcy has been years in the making.
    It is the result of repeated political and financial mismanagement,
    inappropriate financial engineering, and institutional failures.
    The auto industry's initial inability to withstand international competition
    eroded jobs, incomes, and tax receipts.
    As the city suffered, people, companies and jobs migrated to
    other more buoyant locations.
    The subsequent erosion of the tax base made it even more difficult
    to meet expenses associated with public services and pensions,
    both current and future.
    Kevyn Orr, Detroit's emergency financial manager, felt that
    there was no alternative for the city but to declare bankruptcy.
    Similar to the 2009 bankruptcy of two of the big three auto makers
    (Chrysler and General Motors (GM)), the hope is that
    Detroit will reemerge with financial obligations that
    correspond more closely to its income and assets.
     
    Already, tough financial and legal issues have come to the surface,
    including the often-tricky interactions between seemingly-conflicting
    federal and state laws.
    And the most complicated aspects relate to burden sharing –
    or who, among the city's many stakeholders, suppliers and
    creditors should take a hit, and in which relative and absolute sizes.
    This pits pension recipients against creditors, and
    suppliers against beneficiaries of basic public services.
    Should the city pay its senior bond holders while cutting
    the pension payments that retirees earned and get?
    Should bondholders who financed investments in municipal services
    get priority when it comes to allocating payment receipts?
    As the seniority of payments implied by legal contracts
    can often conflict with what many would view as socially just,
    it has not taken long for some to suggest the need
    for the federal government to bailout Detroit.
     
    In addition to protecting municipal workers' pensions from deep cuts
    and countering some of the pressure for yet more outmigration,
    this could also open the door to overriding legal seniority
    (as occurred a few years ago with the Federal government's auto bailout).
    Yet a federal bailout is far from a simple proposition.
    Even if the political will existed, which is far from obvious,
    the spillover effects could be considerable:
    Washington would find it very hard to ring-fence such a bailout
    given that there are other cities and towns that share
    Detroit's terrible combination of a small and contracting revenue base,
    large unfunded pension liabilities, and excessive indebtedness;
    The deeper politicians venture into municipal bailouts,
    the larger the pressure on the Federal budget at a time
    when sequester-related wounds are still fresh and
    few wish to see another debt-ceiling debacle; and
    The larger the number of actual and potential municipal bailouts,
    the greater the temptation to tamper with legal bankruptcy procedures
    that have two distinct objectives: to enable entities to reemerge,
    albeit at a considerable cost, from financial catastrophe
    on a more solid footing (including the possibility of restoring a growth and prosperity path that was precluded by a massive debt overhang); and to reinforce a generally predictable rule of law that plays an important role in maintaining the flow of affordable financing to a whole host of municipal activities and investments.
     
    Whichever way you look at it, Detroit compels the administration
    to consider yet another difficult choice that is not of its making.
    But there is also a silver lining to this new cloud.
    Detroit's tragedy is an extreme component of an unfortunate reality
    that still prevails five years after the onset of the global financial crisis:
    Due overwhelmingly to political polarization and dysfunction,
    both of which repeatedly undermine proper economic governance,
    America has yet to deal effectively and comprehensively
    with its residual problems of insufficient growth and
    employment engines together with pockets of excessive indebtedness.
    Perhaps Detroit's very public financial demise could serve as a catalyst
    to significantly elevate popular awareness of this sad and
    unnecessary reality.
    Perhaps it could serve as a rallying point and unifying vision
    that have eluded Congress for too long.
    Perhaps it could act as a catalyst for the tough decisions that
    are needed and which Congress continues to sidestep.
    This is certainly the hope of many who worry about America's
    persistently high unemployment, its stretched social safety nets,
    and excessive income and wealth inequality.
     
    Maybe, just maybe, Detroit could be a new "Sputnik moment"
    for American politicians and the electorate.
    But if this important hope remains just that -- a hope rather than
    an evolving reality --
    Detroit's considerable human tragedy would end up also
    constituting yet another wasted crisis for America.
No. Subject Date Author Last Update Views
Notice How to write your comments onto a webpage [2] 2016.07.06 운영자 2016.11.20 18193
Notice How to Upload Pictures in webpages 2016.07.06 운영자 2018.10.19 32343
Notice How to use Rich Text Editor [3] 2016.06.28 운영자 2018.10.19 5921
Notice How to Write a Webpage 2016.06.28 운영자 2020.12.23 43838
5662 [Medical] Genetic mutation linked to severe obesity [3] 2013.07.18 이한중*65 2013.07.18 2364
5661 찔레꽃 전설 ( 여름이면 생각이 나는 꽃 ) [6] 2013.07.19 홍초미#65 2013.07.19 3879
5660 도시에서의 죽음 - 김병종 [4] 2013.07.19 운영자 2013.07.19 3753
5659 President Obama Offers a Personal Take on Race in US [4] 2013.07.19 이한중*65 2013.07.19 4020
5658 서울 의대 31회 학술대회 - Application Forms 2013.07.22 김성환*71 2013.07.22 3667
5657 서울 의대 31회 학술대회 - Cruise 일정, Ship 소개 2013.07.22 김성환*71 2013.07.22 3739
5656 서울 의대 31회 학술대회 - 기항지 소개 2013.07.22 김성환*71 2013.07.22 3625
5655 서울 의대 31회 학술대회 - Map and Travel Agent 인사 2013.07.22 김성환*71 2013.07.22 3708
5654 <b>서울 의대 동창 여러분 - 31회 Annual Convention 2014</b> 2013.07.22 김성환*71 2013.07.22 3634
» Could Detroit's tragedy have a silver lining? / by Mohamed A. El-Erian [3] 2013.07.23 이한중*65 2013.07.23 2465
5652 [Hiking] Diamond Lake, Eldora, CO [5] 2013.07.24 운영자 2013.07.24 4447
5651 <b>Sigetop 2013 Third Quarter PDF Edition 2013.07.24 운영자 2013.07.24 3625
5650 <b>[시계탑] Sigetop Archives - All Years since 2008</b> 2013.07.24 운영자 2013.07.24 5182
5649 [Poem] I've Been Away A While / 이한중 2013.07.25 이한중*65 2013.07.25 4220
5648 Scientists Trace Memories [2] 2013.07.25 이한중*65 2013.07.25 2097
5647 Africa today (Revised) [2] 2013.07.26 민경탁*65 2013.07.26 4116
5646 How the Korean products can go ahead of others. 2013.07.27 민경탁*65 2013.07.27 3988
5645 The Last Journey of Jack Lewis [4] file 2013.07.27 강창욱*61 2013.07.27 3830
5644 [Medical] Food For Thought [4] 2013.07.28 이한중*65 2013.07.28 2294
5643 Africa Today Part II [3] 2013.07.29 민경탁*65 2013.07.29 3516