logo

English
                 

General Health Care Reform, A Poll(1)

2009.09.18 09:24

이한중*65 Views:4334



Pro-Reform Doctors Detest Status Quo And
Especially Role Played By Insurers

Of the 1,376 physicians who answered our survey, 65% said "no" to proposed reforms. But that leaves 454, or 33%, who do support them.

How do they feel about reform? And why do they support it?

On Thursday, we let those who oppose Congress' health reforms sound off. Today, it's the supporters' turn. All of the quotes in this story were taken from written responses to our poll.

For those who haven't read the first two installments, the IBD/TIPP Poll was conducted by mail, with questionnaires sent out Aug. 28 to 25,600 doctors nationwide.

The doctor sample was purchased from a list broker. One hundred of those responding were retired, and their answers were excluded from the final results.

Coverage For All

Those in our poll who expressed support for proposed health care reforms cited a number of reasons, ranging from cost control to fairness. Others expressed a deep resentment of insurance companies.

But perhaps the most common sentiment of supporters in favor of a government plan is that it would presumably cover all 46.3 million of those who currently lack insurance.

"We are all one serious illness away from losing our current standard of living," warned one physician. "If people are too ill to work or are laid off, they lose their employer-based benefits."

"Millions of Americans are uninsured and do not have access to health care," added another doctor.

Others were far more blunt in saying what they wanted. "I believe in socialized medicine," one doctor simply said.

A Right, Not A Privilege

Many in the group of supporters suggested that health insurance coverage not be purchased like other goods and services, but rather that it should be accepted as a fundamental right of citizenship.

"Health care is a right," said one doctor, echoing the simple sentiment of many, "not just a privilege." Added another: "The cost of health care is bankrupting our economy. People deserve health care. It is a right!"

"Health care is a basic social service, like fire, police," said still another. "It makes our country stronger to have a strong community."

A related reason given by some was fairness -- especially for those who are poor or lack insurance. "The poor half of the population gets poor treatment," said one doctor, "and the lower fourth of the population gets very poor treatment."

"It's a way out of poverty for the poor," agreed another. "It's a way to better health for the nation."

"The number of uninsured is a disgrace" is how another physician put it. "The future of the world is related to healthy, well-educated children."

Still others couched their support in anti-corporate terms. Many of these expressed deep anger at insurance companies, which often refuse certain medical procedures or drugs to patients -- even when they might be helped by them.

That said, in our current health care system, for better or for worse, private insurance companies are the main way that costs are controlled.

Doctors' ire over insurers was almost palpable -- especially on the issue of rationing care. Asked why they support health insurance reform, many doctors took the opportunity to unload on insurers.

"Insurance companies already ration care and limit access," one of the doctor respondents said. "A private payer option will provide a 'transparent' bureaucracy that at least the doctors and patients will have a chance of dealing with."

'Corporate Thievery'

One physician railed: "I prefer to accept government inefficiency rather than corporate thievery. We should rid the country of greedy insurance CEOs and all other branches of organized crime."

"Health care for all -- stop insurance companies from denying care for pre-existing diagnoses," said another.

"The current health system is not patient-oriented -- it is big business and HMOs that run the show and tell doctors what to do," noted a medical professional. "Their profits paint the picture."

"Private insurance companies interfere with medical care by denying coverage," yet another doctor said. "Their goal is to increase profits, and they do this by low payments to doctors and hospitals and by denying claims and by refusing to authorize procedures."

"Someone has to break the power of big insurance," another respondent said. "Twenty cents out of every dollar goes to health care, (with) 47 million uninsured and (mortality and morbidity) rates similar to nations spending half as much."

On a related note, "rising health care costs" were cited frequently as a main reason for supporting reform -- even though most estimates put the cost of a federally funded health care program over 10 years at $1 trillion or more.

Even the pared-down version released by Sen. Max Baucus, D-Mont., this week carried a hefty $856 billion price tag.

Today the U.S. spends roughly $2.3 trillion on health care. Roughly 47% of that is already controlled by the government, which runs the Medicare, Medicaid, Veterans Administration and S-Chip programs.

Yet, with costs rising much faster than inflation, some doctors felt only government could control spending.

"Ethically, I support universal coverage," said one caregiver. "We need to get some constraints on runaway use of technology, referrals (and) waste. (We need) priorities in spending."

"It will cover the 45 million Americans who are uninsured and will bring down costs and the national deficit in the long term," was how one doctor saw it.

"Private insurers/administrative costs are 30% of health care costs," one reform supporter said. "(We) need a unified, nationalized complete overhaul of the entire system. ... Our current system violates the civil rights of the poor and the sick."

For some, the deficiencies of the current mixed system far outweigh the uncertainties of letting the government take over the remainder of the private health care system.

"Nobody knows what the play will be," said one doctor. "But we absolutely need to do something."

Rationing

Others noted that cost controls were inevitable and necessary, no matter what the system. That means rationing is inevitable.

"The current system of rationing health care is arbitrary and irrational," said one respondent. "(It) leads to greater morbidity and mortality, negatively affects productivity and GDP, (and) handicaps U.S. companies in global markets."

"The current system is imploding on itself," groused another doctor. "Thirty years of cost shifting to cover noncompensated care has resulted in no one knowing what any given service actually costs."

Another cited "too many uninsured people, pre-existing-conditions limits, lack of portability and too much insurance company profits" as signs that "private industry has failed."

Others, in effect, just threw up their hands over the current system.

"Any change has to be better than what we have now," said one in this camp.

IBD systematically went through all 1,295 written responses to our survey. We were struck by the sincerity of both sides of the physicians' debate. But the differences between the two camps were wide.

No. Subject Date Author Last Update Views
Notice How to write your comments onto a webpage [2] 2016.07.06 운영자 2016.11.20 18193
Notice How to Upload Pictures in webpages 2016.07.06 운영자 2018.10.19 32343
Notice How to use Rich Text Editor [3] 2016.06.28 운영자 2018.10.19 5919
Notice How to Write a Webpage 2016.06.28 운영자 2020.12.23 43838
342 Sam Yoon 후보 낙선 [6] 2009.09.23 운영자 2009.09.23 7202
341 ♫ 음악형식.. 베토벤/황제 PC [8] 2009.09.23 김명순*70음대 2009.09.23 6733
340 ♥ 고혈압-3 [1] 2009.09.21 이종구*57 2009.09.21 9883
339 ♫ 오페라 이야기..비제/진주잡이 [4] 2009.09.21 김명순*70음대 2009.09.21 10911
338 Na-Yeon Choi wins the Samsung LPGA Championship [4] 2009.09.20 운영자 2009.09.20 7013
337 What a wonderful world, we live [6] 2009.09.20 황규정*65 2009.09.20 7854
336 Best Places for a Healthy Retirement [3] 2009.09.20 이한중*65 2009.09.20 4551
335 무의촌 시절의 회상 [6] 2009.09.19 유석희*72 2009.09.19 7019
334 Sam Yoon - Boston Mayoral election news [5] 2009.09.19 운영자 2009.09.19 6714
» Health Care Reform, A Poll(1) [1] 2009.09.18 이한중*65 2009.09.18 4334
332 Hiking at Diamond Lake, CO [4] 2009.09.18 정길화*65 2009.09.18 6444
331 가을이 묻어 왔습니다... [4] 2009.09.17 유석희*72 2009.09.17 8796
330 Class Website Links and Other Links에 대해서 [2] 2009.09.17 운영자 2009.09.17 7999
329 미시간의 이른 가을 [2] 2009.09.17 이한중*65 2009.09.17 7846
328 [re] 가을의 노래 [2] 2009.09.17 이한중*65 2009.09.17 8242
327 포도주의 역사 [2] 2009.09.16 이종구*57 2009.09.16 10203
326 수련꽃 피는 9월의 Brooklyn Botanical Garden [8] 2009.09.16 황규정*65 2009.09.16 7126
325 2009 H1N1 Swine Influenza (일반 시민을 위한 글) [7] 2009.09.15 운영자 2009.09.15 6481
324 가을이 가기 전에 [5] 2009.09.14 유석희*72 2009.09.14 7694
323 ♥ 고혈압-2 2009.09.14 이종구*57 2009.09.14 9445