logo

English
                 

Opinion column - Denver Post

Bigotry is un-American, but so is tribalism

By Christine M. Flowers
The Philadelphia Inquirer
Posted: 09/21/2013


Miss America Nina Davuluri poses for photographers following her crowning in Atlantic City, N.J. - In this Sunday, Sept. 15, 2013 file photo, Miss America Nina Davuluri poses for photographers following her crowning in Atlantic City, N.J. For some who observe the progress of people of color in the U.S., Davaluri's victory in the Miss America pageant shows that Indian-Americans can become icons even in parts of mainstream American culture that once seemed closed. (AP Photo/Mel Evans)

To paraphrase Shakespeare, uneasy lies the bouffant that wears the tiara.

Who would have thought, in the joyful anticipation of the pageant's return to Atlantic City, that the coronation of the new Miss America would be fraught with controversy.

Yes, one contestant had tattoos and combat boots, but she was also hot, blond and the favorite among "real, 100 percent Americans." Which, come to think of it, was part of the controversy.

Nina Davuluri was crowned queen, prompting jubilation among some and revulsion among others. The first Indian-American to be elevated to the symbolic throne presented herself as the "diversity" contestant, which is a little strange since her first runner-up was of Chinese descent, one of the other ladies had Native American blood running through her veins and the runway was filled with a rainbow of skin colors, from dark chocolate to freckle-speckled.

But you understood where the former Miss New York was coming from when she said that she was "thankful there are children watching at home who can finally relate to the new Miss America." She was channeling the philosophy that makes this country great, the recognition that we are all immigrants and that the most beautiful American Miss is the one in New York Harbor.

Still, I'm always a bit uncomfortable when someone talks about how great it is that little kids can "finally relate" to someone primarily based on cultural complicity. It dilutes, for me, the potency of that wonderful masala stew in our national melting pot. Children should be able to identify with accomplishment regardless of color, religion, physical ability or political affiliation.

It is Miss "America," after all, not Miss "Special Interest Group." When Nina made reference to those non-Caucasian kids who would likely be delighted at her win (because let's be honest, she wasn't exactly thinking about Marcia Brady), I had a brief flashback to Michelle Obama, who made an offhand but ill-advised statement about finally being proud of her country after husband Barack won the Democratic nomination for president.

And then, all of that went out the window when I saw what happened moments after the tiara was affixed to her head. Social media went crazy, with people making very specific comments about why this lovely Indian-American didn't represent them. The pageant's Facebook page started filling up with comments like "Disgusted that a true 100 percent American did not win," and Twitter fielded outrageous attacks on her patriotism.

My first thought was that people who make a big deal about national purity aren't that far removed from the guys who manned Auschwitz in the 1930s. Anyone who questions the legitimacy of a person based on the fact that they diverge from the mythic blond (even dark-rooted) ideal should take a remedial civics class.

And as someone who spends most of the day dealing with people who want to become Americans and make huge sacrifices to that end, the thought that my native-born brothers and sisters could be racist enough to attack another native-born sibling because she looks more Bollywood than Hollywood is enough to make me join the ACLU (not really, but I wanted to show the lengths to which I'd be driven).

The story doesn't end there, however. There is some blame to be laid at the sea-dipping toes of the newest beauty queen. Nina Davuluri didn't deserve any of the invective thrown at her by cowardly racists typing away in their parents' basements. She showed a great deal of dignity in reacting to the attacks by saying, "I have to rise above that. I always viewed myself as first and foremost an American."

Which is, indeed, admirable. But if that's the case, perhaps she shouldn't have started talking about the little children out there who, finally, would feel as if they had a piece of the Indian-American samosa simply because the lady in the sash looked like them. Diversity is always valuable, except when you start considering it an end in and of itself.

There is no excuse for bigotry. The knuckle-dragging idiots who wanted Miss Kansas to win because she was the "real" American are making it a lot easier for the Nina Davuluris of the world to continue advancing the kind of diversity agenda that, whether we like it or not, tends to divide instead of unite.

No. Subject Date Author Last Update Views
Notice How to write your comments onto a webpage [2] 2016.07.06 운영자 2016.11.20 18186
Notice How to Upload Pictures in webpages 2016.07.06 운영자 2018.10.19 32336
Notice How to use Rich Text Editor [3] 2016.06.28 운영자 2018.10.19 5909
Notice How to Write a Webpage 2016.06.28 운영자 2020.12.23 43827
27 Afghanistan and the U.S. Today [5] 2021.08.30 운영자 2021.08.31 7945
26 함춘학술상과 장기려 의도상의 지원자격설정에 대해서 [2] 2011.08.04 운영자 2011.08.04 5956
25 [re] His Holiness: The Secret Papers of Benedict XVI [2] 2012.10.06 김이영*66 2012.10.06 5472
24 일본의 뻔뻔함에 대한 칼럼 두개 [2] 2012.09.05 김이영*66 2012.09.05 5198
23 어설픈 세상보기 1-이동흡헌재소장피지명자 자진사퇴는? 2013.02.07 김이영*66 2013.02.07 5070
22 "8.10" 독도의 기적과 그때 그시절(8/24)에서 운영자 답글에 대한 나의 답변 [4] 2012.08.25 김성심*57 2012.08.25 4722
21 당신들만의 원칙 [2] 2013.03.10 김이영*66 2013.03.10 4595
20 지도자 [1] 2013.03.13 김이영*66 2013.03.13 4418
19 "8.10" 독도의 기적과 그때 그시절(8/24)에서 운영자 답글에 대한 나의 답변 [7] 2012.08.26 김이영*66 2012.08.26 4355
18 독도. 그 섬에 살고싶다 [2] 2012.03.31 김창현#70 2012.03.31 4020
17 South Korea Puts Anger Aside After Olympic Skating Disappointment [4] 2014.02.22 운영자 2014.02.22 3490
16 조선은 어떻게 500년이나 갔을까? [6] 2013.10.16 김영철*61 2013.10.16 2612
» On Miss America - Bigotry is un-American, but so is tribalism [3] 2013.09.22 운영자 2013.09.22 2598
14 Yankees are talking about North Korea [2] 2012.01.04 Rover 2012.01.04 2518
13 [인문학 Lecture] 조정래 - 우리는 중국을 알아야한다, 우리 한국사회... [2] 2014.04.12 운영자 2014.04.12 2097
12 Who Shut Down the Government? [2] 2013.10.07 김영철*61 2013.10.07 2062
11 The Phony Martyrdom of Kim Davis 2015.09.04 운영자 2015.09.04 576
10 중국식 한문 발음 [14] 2019.10.11 정관호*63 2020.09.22 394
9 미국 교포가 올린 만화 글 [3] 2017.11.24 운영자 2017.11.25 236
8 서울 고 삼인방 in action--A tribute & prayer, 손열음 [7] 2018.05.12 조중행*69 2018.07.19 222